November 02, 2026

Correcting False Information: New York Times Article

On 19th October the New York Times (NYT) published the article ‘How a Trillion-Dollar Industry Launders Illegal Gold’, written by Justin Scheck. The piece contains errors concerning the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) and Istanbul Gold Refinery (IGR), one of LBMA’s Good Delivery List Refiners.  

LBMA takes the integrity of gold supply chains seriously. In accordance with our Good Delivery Rules and processes, we have removed numerous refiners from the Good Delivery List since the introduction of the Responsible Gold Guidance, and required many corrective action plans and special audits. Review Process Case Studies are available on our website. 

Prior to publication, LBMA provided Mr Scheck with a detailed briefing and responded at length to follow-up questions. The information LBMA provided was not reflected in the published article, which includes several serious inaccuracies. 

As we informed the NYT before publication, there was one independent assurance engagement covering IGR’s FY2023. The Assurance Statement, signed and dated 29th March 2024, was not amended and its conclusion did not change. LBMA did not request or direct that any assurance report be backdated. 

It is standard practice, as part of LBMA’s quality control process, to request clarifications in a Refiner’s Compliance Report where this improves transparency of publicly available information. The Refiner’s Compliance Report was expanded by two pages to include additional audited information. The additional text, in Step 2 (risk identification and assessment), sets out in more detail the due diligence IGR carried out on its gold sourcing, including from Madagascar. It does not change the report’s conclusion. Ordinarily, we publish only the final version of the Refiner’s Compliance Report on the LBMA website. In this instance, we published both the first and the second version together with the Assurance Statement, for transparency (and it is this composite version that has been on our website from 7th October, 2024). 

The Assurance Review did identify non-conformances with the Responsible Gold Guidance. None of them were zero-tolerance issues, and a Corrective Action Plan was put in place to address them. This is consistent with requirements outlined in both the Responsible Gold Guidance and the OECD Due Diligence Guidance for Responsible Minerals from Conflict Affected and High-Risk Areas. 

LBMA advances standards, reviews the independent assurance provided against those standards, and takes action in line with its rules and procedures when concerns arise. We are not a regulator, we do not control mines or mining operators, and assurance cannot certify a mine or guarantee an outcome. The OECD guidance applies to every participant in the gold supply chain. That is why our approach favours continued engagement, with corrective action and monitoring, and treats disengagement as a last resort where risks cannot be mitigated. 

We remain committed to strengthening responsible sourcing, acting on evidence and requiring measurable improvement.